News

Patent Fun Roundup: Android Legal Cases in One Week

By Android in Canada Editorial TeamUpdated

Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.

The odd request

Apple asked a U.S. district court to obscure the Samsung logo on a video display shown to jurors. The writer compared it to old TV rules that removed brand names, or blurred shirts on passersby. A Samsung-side expert was quoted arguing that showing the logo could tell jurors that Samsung contributes technology to the U.S. government. The writer was not convinced.

A judge loses patience

Judge Posner scolded Apple’s lawyers over frivolous filings. The headline quoted the judge as saying there had been enough of them.

Nokia enters the fray

Nokia sued HTC, ViewSonic and RIM for patent infringement. The writer wondered whether the timing came from real concern or from Nokia’s reduced market share after tying its future to Microsoft and Windows Phone.

Apple against Motorola

Apple lost another claim, this time to Motorola. It had tried to stretch a finger swipe patent to cover the area tap that Motorola uses. The ruling went against Apple, with the reasoning that if consumers distinguish between a swipe and a tap, the gestures are not interchangeable.

Motorola and Microsoft

Microsoft obtained a temporary restraining order that blocked Motorola from pursuing a suit in North America, after Motorola had won some cases in Europe. Motorola appealed to the Ninth Circuit.

Oracle and Google

The jury verdict in the Oracle and Google case was postponed until Monday. The writer noted the case had gone back and forth, and that opinion online was split. The outcome is not covered in this roundup.

Frequently asked questions

What was Patentfun?

A weekly roundup of legal news involving Android.

Who won the Oracle and Google case?

This roundup was written before the verdict, so it does not say.

Why do patent cases matter to Android users?

Rulings can affect which features and devices companies are allowed to sell.

This page is part of an informational archive. See the disclaimer.