Featured

Patent Fun Weekly Roundup: Apple v. Samsung Goes to the Jury

By Android in Canada Editorial TeamUpdated

Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.

Other news

  • Apple, Samsung, Microsoft and Google might collaborate to acquire Kodak patents. The author doubted it would last.
  • Motorola sued Apple over iPhone and iPad patents. The author compared that with Apple’s suits, which rest largely on rounded-corner design, whereas Motorola’s rest on technology patents. The author did not like that Motorola sought a ban rather than licensing fees.
  • Apple licensed essential design patents to Microsoft, according to Reuters.

Apple v. Samsung developments

  • Samsung persuaded the judge to remove three devices from the trial. Apple then rested its case.
  • Samsung opened its defence, arguing that Apple borrowed from earlier work such as LaunchTile and the DiamondTouch table, and that the iPhone design was not unique.
  • An Apple survey showed reasons customers who considered an iPhone bought Android instead.
  • Judge Lucy Koh urged both companies to settle, saying it was time for peace.
  • One of Apple’s patents, covering the “bounce back” scroll effect, could be found invalid.
  • Apple accused Samsung of bad faith over standards-essential patents.
  • Neither side narrowed its claims, so the jury would decide.
  • Samsung asked for $421.8 million, while Apple had asked for $2.5 billion.

The author’s view

The author hoped the case would help end some of the silliness without waiting for patent reform. The outcome of the verdict is not covered here.

Frequently asked questions

What was the dispute about?

Apple accused Samsung's devices of copying iPhone and iPad features and design. Samsung made counterclaims.

Who decided it?

A jury, after both sides rested.

This page is part of an informational archive. See the disclaimer.