Topic guide

#Patentfun: Weekly Android Patent Roundups

By Android in Canada Editorial TeamUpdated

Apple versus Samsung

This was the biggest thread. Apple won a ban on the Galaxy Tab in Germany, then took the fight to Samsung’s home market in Japan while also battling in the US and Australia. In the later issues:

  • Apple asked for a US ban on the Galaxy Tab again, and Samsung asked the court for sanctions over allegedly withheld evidence.
  • Settlement talks ended without an agreement and the case went to trial on June 7.
  • A request to block the Galaxy S III launch was denied by a judge, and a federal judge cleared Apple of infringing a Samsung patent ahead of a summer trial.
  • A court in Germany sided with Apple on design rights, while Samsung’s prior art was expected to beat Apple’s new design rights in a German tablet case.
  • The Galaxy Tab 10.1N was released in Germany, with a changed look, to get around the ban. Later a Tab 10.1 ban was sent back to Judge Koh’s court and the tablet went back on sale.
  • After the 1 billion dollar verdict, issues covered the jury foreman’s interviews, admitted gaps in patent review, Apple’s motion for a new trial and a ruling that the verdict lacked detail to enhance more than 6.4% of the award for wilful infringement.
  • Samsung also lost an Italian ban request, and a US appeals court refused to pause a Galaxy Tab ban. A US court ordered a Galaxy Tab sales ban over a device-search patent.

Apple versus HTC and Motorola

  • Apple sued HTC in Munich over slide to unlock and a photo flip swipe in the gallery, the same two patents already won against Motorola.
  • HTC lost its last ITC appeal against Apple, then an S3 Graphics case against Apple was delayed and later dismissed, though HTC was expected to appeal. Google transferred patents to HTC, but a judge denied HTC the chance to use Google patents against Apple.
  • HTC won a slide to unlock dispute against Apple in the UK, and a federal judge turned away Apple’s protests so HTC patents were likely to stand. Apple narrowed its second ITC case, dropping a patent and 34 claims, and pushed for a US import ban on 29 HTC devices.
  • An ITC judge also ruled Apple had not violated Samsung’s patents. A report said HTC could win a ban on the new iPad and iPhone based on LTE patents.
  • Apple won an injunction against Motorola over slide to unlock in Germany, Motorola lost a rubber-banding case there, and a judge agreed to hold injunction hearings for Apple and Motorola. Another report called Apple’s argument in Chicago disingenuous.

Google, Oracle and Microsoft

  • Google filed for a new lockscreen interface patent, earned a pattern unlock patent, and was working on a notification bar patent. It also bought more patents from IBM, and a face-to-unlock patent was later granted.
  • Oracle and Google started looking for mediation. A jury later found Google did not infringe two Oracle patents, and the author predicted appeals.
  • Motorola Mobility directors voted for the Google purchase. Motorola asked Apple for 347 million dollars for two wireless patents and claimed iCloud infringed patents in Germany.
  • Microsoft was said to earn more from each Android phone than from its own phones. It asked a US judge to stop Motorola from enforcing its German wins, and a German court later issued an injunction in the Microsoft and Motorola dispute.
  • Barnes and Noble stood up to Microsoft and asked for an investigation, while Android makers in China formed an alliance for defence. Acer was forced to halt a device launch over Android compliance, because straying too far from the OHA standard has consequences.

Oddities

  • CarrierIQ sent a cease and desist letter to a researcher over software that logged phone activity, then cancelled it and apologised after help from the EFF.
  • Vivid sent a cease and desist letter to HTC about the name of its phone.
  • Apple was reported to sue a Polish online grocery site and a company whose logo looked like LG’s.
  • A boycott Apple campaign ran in one summer week, and Apple co-founder Woz said of the Apple versus Samsung war that it was something to hate. An ITU patent roundtable on FRAND was scheduled for October. Canada’s Copyright Modernization Act received Royal Assent, and Judge Posner questioned whether most industries need patents.

The GooPhone joke

The Chinese GooPhone, an Android phone resembling the expected iPhone, came with a plan to sue Apple in China if the new iPhone looked like it. The reasoning was that China gives design rights to whoever releases first. The makers of Goophone made the same threat ahead of the iPhone 5.

Frequently asked questions

Which patents did Apple use against HTC and Motorola?

Slide to unlock and the swipe between photos in the gallery.

Did Google win against Oracle?

A jury found Google did not infringe two Oracle patents, but the column noted appeals and paperwork would follow.

What happened to the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in Germany?

A ban was granted, Samsung released the 10.1N, and a later US ban was sent back to Judge Koh's court.

Is this information current?

No. These were weekly snapshots of cases from that era and most outcomes have long been settled.

This page is part of an informational archive. See the disclaimer.