Patent Fun Weekly Roundup: Apple, Samsung, Google and Trolls
Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.
New complaints and rulings
- The US trade commission was set to investigate Apple over patent infringement after a complaint from Motorola, which also sought bans on some Apple products.
- Samsung was reported to be preparing infringement claims against the iPhone 5 on eight patents.
- A German court found that Samsung and Motorola did not infringe Appleās touch event patent.
- A German court granted Microsoft an injunction against Google, covering a patent on a soft input panel system.
- Apple was criticised for using a design resembling a Swiss railway clock.
The author argued that two companies can reach the same idea and that the implementation, not the idea, is what should be protected.
Troll watch
A patent troll sued both Google and Apple. Skyhook Wireless filed a new suit against Google over nine US patents on Wi-Fi positioning, including methods for estimating position error and detecting moved access points.
Crowdsourcing bad patents
Google, Stack Exchange and the US patent office joined a platform meant to help the public challenge overbroad patents.
Apple v. Samsung
- Samsung asked an appeals court for a limited remand so the judge could dissolve an injunction on the Galaxy Tab 10.1.
- Apple asked for $707 million more and for bans.
- Samsung asked for judgment as a matter of law or a new trial, saying the trial was unfair.
- Samsung also worked out how the jury reached its damages figures, except for the Galaxy Tab 10.1.
Frequently asked questions
What is a patent troll?
A company that holds patents mainly to sue others, rather than to make products.
Are these cases still active?
This is a record of one week long ago, and outcomes are not covered here.