Android Patent Disputes Roundup: Apple, Samsung and Motorola in Court
Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.
Samsung loses an appeal in Germany
Apple had first sued Samsung because it argued that Samsung’s products looked too much like its own, and it won an injunction. Samsung appealed and lost on design grounds, then took the case to a higher German court. That court upheld the injunction on the Galaxy Tab 10.1 again, but on a different basis: unfair competition, not Apple’s design right. The author found the reasoning hard to follow and noted that the term is vague, so the ruling may not carry over to courts in other countries.
No ban on the Galaxy Tab 10.1N or Galaxy Nexus
Another German court rejected Apple’s request to stop sales of the Galaxy Tab 10.1N and the Galaxy Nexus. The case rested on a patent covering touch technology rather than on design. The judge said Samsung had shown it was more likely than not that the patent would be revoked, because similar technology was on the market before the patent was filed.
Apple against Motorola in North America
A judge agreed with Apple on how to read one of the patents in its dispute with Motorola, a patent relating to a real-time API. The author said this interpretation could have wide effects on Android devices, though the technical details were unclear to them.
Motorola’s win over Apple’s cloud service
In Germany, Motorola won an injunction affecting Apple’s iCloud and client devices. The dispute concerned how a cloud service can use push technology to reach a phone or tablet. Apple temporarily pulled products that would infringe, then obtained a temporary reprieve. The author noted that push technology has existed for years and is built into nearly every device.
Apple widens its claims in Australia
Apple’s fight against Samsung had started in Australia, where it wanted to keep Samsung’s tablets off the market. The latest development was that Apple expanded its claims to cover 10 different devices.
Frequently asked questions
What does unfair competition mean in this case?
The roundup did not explain the grounds in detail, and the author said the term appeared vague.
Were the Galaxy Tab 10.1N and Galaxy Nexus banned?
Not by the court described here, which rejected Apple's request for a ban.
Are these cases still ongoing?
This page records one week of events from a past period. Later rulings are not covered.