Apple v. Samsung Verdict Aftermath: A Weekly Patent Round-Up
Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.
After the verdict
The big verdict was behind everyone, but a new phase began with arguments over injunctive relief and appeals. Google said most of the claims did not relate to core Android. Apple and Samsung both prepared for a fight over triple damages, injunctions and whether any reasonable jury could have reached that decision. The writer questioned whether a highly technical case belongs in a jury’s hands. Samsung said it would use all necessary measures to resist injunctions and wanted US injunction hearings moved up, but the judgement meant Samsung would not face the court on damages until December 6.
Other disputes
- Apple and Samsung’s business ties. Samsung was seen as unlikely to give up its manufacturing partnership with Apple despite the trial loss.
- Antitrust. The verdict was suggested as possibly helpful to Google in a federal antitrust investigation.
- Germany. Google’s Motorola unit was forced to accept a FRAND patent licence to Apple. FRAND means fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory.
- HTC. HTC’s chair said the company had no plans to settle its patent suit with Apple.
- Japan. Apple lost a patent case against Samsung, which the writer called essentially a wash.
- More devices. Apple added devices to a second suit, including the Note and the S3.
- Talks. Google and Apple’s chief executives were reportedly discussing patents by phone.
- New Zealand. The country banned software patents, though developers saw loopholes.
The jury foreman
The writer was angry at public comments from the jury foreman. Several analysts argued that the foreman’s explanation showed a misunderstanding of prior art. That is the commentary of the writer and other outlets, not a ruling.
Frequently asked questions
What is a FRAND licence?
A promise to license standards-essential patents on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms.
Did the verdict end the case?
No. Appeals and injunction hearings were still ahead.
Is this post current?
No. It is a dated news round-up of past disputes.