Galaxy Note 7 Fires, Recall and Aftermath: What Happened
Recall and shutdown
Samsung first recalled the phone, then found the replacements were also catching fire. It halted sales and exchanges and told owners to power down and stop using the device, with remedies of a full refund or an exchange for a Galaxy S7 or S7 Edge. Samsung Canada said owners of original and replacement units should power down, with refund details promised and a phone line to call. More than a month had passed since the first fire reports.
A Wall Street Journal report said engineers had run X-ray and CT scans on early batteries and found a bulge in Samsung SDI cells that a second supplier’s did not show. With complaints piling up, the company chief ordered a recall, and two weeks later it handed out replacements with the other supplier’s batteries. The report argued this rush may have contributed to the phone’s end.
Airlines and forced shutdowns
After the US aviation regulator banned the Note 7 from flights, Transport Canada did the same. Its notice said the phone was covered by Special Provision 137 of the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Regulations, which bars carrying lithium ion batteries that are damaged or defective. Carriers were told to warn passengers before boarding and deny boarding to anyone carrying one, including in checked bags.
- US: Samsung worked with carriers including Verizon and T-Mobile on an update that would stop the phone from charging.
- South Korea: 85% of 950,000 units were returned, so about 140,000 were still in use, charge was limited to 60% and an option to limit to 15% was being considered.
- New Zealand: Samsung and the telecommunications forum said Note7 phones would be blocked from mobile networks from November 18, leaving only WiFi, after two warnings to owners. Earlier updates had capped charge at 60%.
What caused the fires
Samsung said its investigation, which used three independent companies, tested more than 200,000 Note7 units and 30,000 batteries and recreated the fires. It found no hardware, software or design fault with the phone. Both battery batches had faults:
| Batch | Supplier | Problem |
|---|---|---|
| A | Samsung SDI | Battery casing too small, deforming upper corners, plus thin internal separators |
| B | Amperex | Missing or misaligned insulation tape, or a thin internal separator |
Before the result, a report claimed the Galaxy S8 would use Samsung SDI batteries and that a “strategic defect” was behind the disaster. Another report said Samsung tested the batteries in its own lab, the only manufacturer to do so among certified labs, whereas others used outside labs; Samsung said it found no problems in its own tests.
Financial and company effects
- The affair was to cost more than $5 billion, with analysts at one point expecting a $17 billion hit.
- Mobile division operating profit in Q3 was about $87.8 million, down 96%.
- Staff in the 26,600 person Phone Group feared job losses, though employees stayed positive about solving the cause.
- Even so, Q4 operating income was forecast to rise 50% year over year to about $10.3 billion CAD, thanks to OLED panels and chips, and shares rose 43%.
- Analysts suggested an earlier Galaxy S8 launch, with curved AMOLED displays, to recover.
The refurbished Note7 Fan Edition
Samsung planned refurbished Note7 units for select markets but not Canada. Leaked images showed model SM-N935 with Android 7.0 Nougat and a 3,200 mAh battery instead of 3,500 mAh. It became the Galaxy Note7 FE, reported for sale in South Korea on July 7 at about $803 CAD, with up to 400,000 units planned. An earlier report called it the Note 7R at about $841 CAD, roughly 29% below the $1,186 CAD original.
Parody and the internet
Samsung filed a copyright claim against a YouTube video showing the Note7 used as an explosive in a modified Grand Theft Auto V. The video was removed briefly, then restored after the creator counter-claimed.
Frequently asked questions
What caused the Note7 fires?
Two battery faults, one in each supplier's batch, according to Samsung.
Could the Note7 fly on planes in Canada?
No, Transport Canada banned it from air transport.
Was the refurbished Note7 sold in Canada?
No, it was planned for select markets that excluded Canada.
Did Samsung recover financially?
Its overall profit rebounded, led by chips and OLED panels, while mobile profit fell sharply in Q3.