Featured

Galaxy Nexus vs Galaxy S II LTE: A Week-Long Comparison

By Android in Canada Editorial TeamUpdated

Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.

Design

The Galaxy Nexus feels light at first, but the reviewer dropped it on the first day and got away with a scuffed corner and minor scratches near the front camera, so it proved sturdy. The front has no logos and no physical or touch buttons, which lets the screen reach lower than usual. There is a notification LED on the chin, a micro USB port and pogo pins on the side for docks that did not exist yet. The speaker sits in the centre of the bulge at the back, and the reviewer often covered it with a hand.

Performance

The Nexus had a 1.2 GHz dual-core processor, 1 GB of RAM and 16 or 32 GB of storage, and ran Ice Cream Sandwich 4.0.1. The S II LTE ran Gingerbread 2.3.5. Both felt fast, and the Nexus took the edge for the newer software.

Sound and storage

  • The Nexus speaker sounded tinny and not loud enough, so some notifications went unheard. A strong vibration motor helped.
  • The S II LTE reached a much higher volume with a fuller sound.
  • Canadians could only get the 16 GB Nexus, with about 13 GB usable and no microSD slot. The 32 GB model belonged to an LTE version that was not coming to Canada.
  • The S II LTE takes a microSD card up to 32 GB.

Battery

The reviewer disagreed with other sites that praised the Nexus battery. On a day with hours of Bluetooth music streaming plus texts, email and browsing, the Nexus arrived home at 40 to 50 percent and died around early evening. Idle RAM use was also high, around 300 MB or more used compared with roughly 150 MB on earlier phones, and the reviewer wondered whether that fed the drain. The S II LTE lasted longer even with its LTE radio in use.

Network, rooting and camera

Only the S II LTE could use Canadian LTE, because the Nexus LTE model uses different bands. Both phones can be rooted. The reviewer rooted the S II LTE to remove bloatware but skipped it on the Nexus, since Ice Cream Sandwich can disable apps itself.

The Nexus camera shot about three pictures per second with zero shutter lag, although a shaky hand gave blurry results. Video had stabilization on both cameras. The S II LTE took slightly better individual pictures and had a widescreen option, but the Nexus got the camera point for speed.

Screen

The Nexus has a 4.65-inch 720 x 1280 display that looks sharp, but with auto brightness the colours looked faded. The S II LTE has a 4.5-inch 480 x 800 Super AMOLED Plus screen that is brighter and more vivid. Because the Nexus uses on-screen buttons, the usable area was closer than the sizes suggest. The reviewer gave this one to the S II LTE.

Problems seen during the week

  • Poor battery life.
  • Music duplicating over Bluetooth, with laggy controls that a reset did not cure.
  • Photos uploaded to Google+ shrinking to a tiny size.
  • Signal dropping about once a day until a reboot.
  • Low maximum volume.

The reviewer expected most of these to be fixed by updates and described them as early-adopter issues.

Final thoughts

By the end of the week the reviewer missed LTE speeds and the microSD storage and put the SIM back in the S II LTE. Both phones were called great, and the choice depends on what you want.

Frequently asked questions

Did the Galaxy Nexus work on Canadian LTE?

Not in the version available in Canada. The LTE model used different bands.

Could the Galaxy Nexus use a memory card?

No. It had no microSD slot.

Which phone won overall?

For this reviewer, the Galaxy S II LTE, mainly on battery, screen, sound and storage.

This page is part of an informational archive. See the disclaimer.