Google Pixel and Pixel XL Review Roundup: What Critics Said
Archive note. This story reflects what was known when it was first covered. Prices, availability and carrier offers are historical. For the current picture, start with the topic guides.
The phones
The Pixel and Pixel XL differ mainly in size. The XL has a bigger, sharper display and a larger battery. Processor, memory, camera and headphone jack are the same. HTC built them, and Google designed them.
Scores and verdicts
| Outlet | Score | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| The Verge | 9/10 | Remarkably good for a first effort, matching the best phones on speed, camera and assistant. Preferred the XL for battery life. |
| CNET | 4.5/5 | Polished and well crafted, with a one-piece aluminum design more elegant than earlier Nexus phones. |
| Engadget | 86/100 | Fast Snapdragon 821 and a fantastic camera, but a dull look and a price that could be lower. |
Other opinions
- TechCrunch saw the phones as a step beyond the Nexus line that shows what Android can do when hardware and software come from one company.
- Ars Technica said the design resembles other HTC phones and questioned why the $750 Pixel XL lacks the stereo speakers of the $500 Nexus 6P.
- Wired noted that the Assistant would be exclusive to the Pixel for the foreseeable future.
- 9to5Google highlighted the camera, the Assistant and Daydream VR readiness.
- VentureBeat advised choosing by hand size and use, since the only trade-off is screen, dimensions and battery.
Frequently asked questions
Which size is better?
It comes down to hand size and battery needs, as the two share the same core hardware.
Who made the Pixel?
HTC assembled it, and Google designed and developed it.
Are these phones still supported?
No. They are early Pixel models and no longer receive updates.