I would like to express my gratitude to the team at Samsung Canada for providing me with the opportunity to test a unit. A video has been prepared for your reference (see below).
A brief overview of the comparative data between the two devices is presented below. The highlighted data represents the respective strengths of each device within each category. However, the superiority of the chipset may be a subject of debate.
The comparison is presented in a concise format, divided into a few key categories. In terms of size, stylus, and system OS, the following observations can be made.
Size
Upon initial observation, it became immediately apparent that the device was of considerable girth. However, within a few minutes, the device became comfortable to use. I encountered no difficulties with it. Given that the device is a Bell product, I did not insert a SIM card to test its functionality for making phone calls. However, it is unlikely that the device would be significantly hindered in its functionality as a mobile phone, given its dimensions.
Subsequently, upon returning to my Nexus (which, as previously noted, I characterized as a sizable device), it appeared diminutive in comparison. Tom cautioned me that I would not be able to revert to using the Nexus, but my hand and eyes adapt to the change in size, and the transition is merely a matter of adjustment.
Stylus… err S-Pen
The device may now be used as per the usual procedure. The user may interact with the device in the same manner as would be expected. Utilizing the S-Pen is somewhat distinct from the aforementioned method. I posit that my familiarity with an older Palm device has conditioned my expectations to a greater degree than the soft light touch that is sufficient for this device. In order to achieve the desired result, it is necessary to apply a certain degree of force with the pen (for example, to swipe or click).
The ability to draw is a particularly attractive feature, and it is easy to find oneself using the screenshot and doodling options. Once more, a degree of pressure beyond that which I was previously accustomed to with Palm devices is required. However, it is nevertheless a highly desirable feature to be able to utilise this functionality on a phablet. I am uncertain as to the practical utility of this feature in comparison to its novelty value.
Another aspect that is somewhat problematic is the inability to utilise the stylus on the soft keys of the device. This is a somewhat vexing aspect of the device.
System
I am astonished at the extent to which I have become integrated into the ICS ecosystem. As a result, I have developed a strong aversion to Gingerbread. Notably, the TouchWiz interface also contributes to this perception of slowness and inefficiency, despite the enhanced processing capabilities of the device. It is not the case that performance is an issue; rather, it is the act of navigating the user interface that is problematic.
Furthermore, I have difficulty locating and, in some cases, switching between apps due to the unconventional placement of certain buttons. I am compelled to remark that the process of dismissing a single notification is a particularly vexatious one. It remains unclear whether ICS will resolve all of the aforementioned issues on the Note. However, there is hope that TouchWiz will not introduce further complications.
Additionally, I find the permanent buttons to be less convenient than the soft buttons, which I miss having. In comparison, the permanent buttons feel somewhat outdated. However, this may be perceived as a somewhat pretentious perspective.
Final thoughts
I am intrigued by the potential of NFC, but I am uncertain as to its functionality. It is possible that the issue is caused by a combination of Gingerbread and Ice Cream Sandwich, which may prevent the transfer of data to the Nexus device. It appears that my Nexus device is unable to “beam” data to my wife’s phone, which suggests that there may be an underlying issue with the device itself. In any case, I am keen to test it further, but I am unsure of the source of the problem.
Additionally, the device features an aesthetically pleasing back design, which enhances the tactile experience. The screen bezel with a lip contributes to a perception of enhanced durability.
One final query: would you be so kind as to inform me whether a case or a sleeve is provided with this item?
I will be conducting a video review in the near future (I have been granted access to the device for a two-week period). Are there any specific tests you would like me to perform with it?